Radiant floor systems provide the highest level of heating comfort in conventional homes with low levels of insulation and airtightness. But they are expensive, and do not make much sense for energy efficient homes or for energy savings.
Radiant Floor Heating doesn't make sense in energy efficient homes
Compared with a conventional furnace, radiant floor-heating provides excellent indoor air quality – less dust and less volatile chemicals and toxic particulates circulating around the house. An important issue for people with chemical sensitivities.
It also does not contribute to floor-to-ceiling temperature stratification and provides some energy savings in very cold climates, in conventional homes, if homeowners set their thermostats to the desired setpoints.
On the other hand, hydronic (hot-water) radiant floor heating is expensive to install, whatever its type (slab-on-grand, thin-slab or plate-type).
It simply doesn’t make sense to install a heating system that may cost you $10.000 or $15.000 or more, in homes designed to have a small heating system. You can install a small ductless heat pump system (or other similar system) for a fraction of the price.
This alternative system can also provide lower running costs and lower maintenance costs (they haven't the boilers connected to the radiant floor heating systems...).
Energy savings facts
Radiant floor heating can operate at relatively low temperatures, say, at about 68ºF (20ºC), which is a way of achieving some energy savings...Facts and Myths about radiant floor heating
A fact: radiant floor heating provides high-quality heating comfort;
A myth: radiant floor is more environmentally-friendly than most other heating systems;
A fact: radiant floor heating provides good indoor air quality;
A myth: radiant floor heating is a very energy-efficient option;
A fact: radiant floor heating is one of the most expensive heating systems;
A myth: radiant floor heating has low running costs.
Equally relevant for energy savings is the fact that with radiant floor heating the warmest air is close to the floor and to people, which helps reduce heat loss through the upper parts of the rooms.
Anyway, these savings are modest, even in colder climates, and can be reversed by heat loss to the ground and the walls. Even with a good insulation system under the slab, many radiant-floor heating systems lose a significant amount of heat into the ground.
But there is another important reason that makes ductless heat pumps and room air conditioners (or even new wall gas furnaces) a better choice than radiant floor heating for energy savings.
These other systems are more flexible; they heat quicky, while radiant floor heating systems have a slow response to change (wich can also be responsible for uncomfortable high temperatures in the morning or later in the day). And for homes with small heating loads as energy efficient houses should be, this means that those other alternatives to radiant floor heating consume less energy, during long periods. Or, in other words: ductless heat pumps and other equivalent systems can provide higher energy savings than radiant floor heating, in energy-efficient homes.
electric radiant floor heating
Electric radiant floor heating is less expensive to install than hydronic systems, but it is expensive to run.
About to build a new home?
Read our book (Print and Kindle ebook versions);
Save thousands of dollars;
Avoid costly mistakes and pitfalls.
Our Video on Radiant Floor Heating Types: